Cave Explorers and Geoconservation in the North of England – a Changing Paradigm?

Authors

• Philip Murphy * ¹
• Sam Allshorn ¹

• School of Earth and Environment, University of Leeds, United Kingdom

Abstract

Recent cave exploration in the Yorkshire Dales glaciokarst of the north of England has mainly been achieved through the removal of sediment infill from passages and entrances. This has resulted in the linking of previously fragmented cave systems to produce the world class Three Counties Cave System. This work has resulted in a growing appreciation by cave explorers of the need to conserve the delicate underground environment. A number of new techniques and approaches have been developed in order to limit the effects of exploratory digging on the cave system along with active efforts to clean up the underground legacy of previous generations of cave explorers. These techniques and approaches pioneered here may have wider applicability to karst areas elsewhere in the world where cave exploration has reached a phase which includes the digging through sediment blockages.

Keywords

• Conservation
• Karst
• Caves
• Underground
• Digging
• Engineering

References

1. Allen T (2015). If in doubt – bring it out. Descent 245: 20
2. Allen T (2014). The longest cave. Descent240: 36 
3. Allen T (2012a).The final piece of the jigsaw. Descent 224: 18-21
4. Allen T (2012b). The final piece of the jigsaw. Descent 225: 19-21
5. Allen T (2012c). The three counties media circus. Descent 225: 24-26
6. Allen T (2011). At last, a reality. Descent 223: 32&33
7. Allshorn S & Swire P (2017). Northern caves - The Three Counties System and the North-West. Leeds: High Mead, UK.
8. Benn G (2012). Restoring Christmas Pot. Descent 227: 13
9.  Brook D (1971). Trans Craven: 3^rd generation cavers could complete a 200 mile giant. Descent 18: 16-18.
10. Brook D B (1968). The Three Counties System. University of Leeds Speleological Association Review 3: 15-19.
11. Brown T (2009). Whitewell pot restoration. Descent 211: 10.
12. Chamberlain A.T. (2018). Gazetteer of caves, fissures and rock shelters in Britain containing human remains. http://caveburial.ubss.org.uk/. Retrieved 2018.
13. Cook L B (2004). Anatomy of a dig. 50-52 in: Beck H M (ed). Craven Pothole Club Jubilee Journal. Craven Pothole Club, Skipton, England.
14. Cooper M (2007). Not for the faint hearted: 50 harder caving trips in the Yorkshire Dales. Privately Published. Ingleton, North Yorkshire, UK.
15. Duffy R (2016).Lancaster Hole - entrance replacement. Journal of the Red Rose Cave and Pothole Club 11: 92-95.
16. Hill E (2017). Penghent entrance. Descent 258: 14.
17. Hinde A, Townley H, Stedman N & Brown E 2012. Cave conservation, geodiversity and landscapes in Northern England. 11-14 In O’Regan H J, Faulkner T and Smith I R. Cave archaeology and karst geomorphology of North West England. Field Guide, pp 11-14. Quaternary Research Association. London.
18. Into the abyss: Stretching over three counties and 70 miles, inside Britain's vast and newly pioneered cave system (2010, 26 July).DailyMail: World News. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/home/moslive/article-1296308/Into-abyss-Stretching-counties-70-miles-inside-Britains-vast-newly-pioneered-cave-system.html . Retrieved 20 July 2015. 
19. Lord T & Howard J (2013). Cave archaeology. In Waltham T and Lowe D (eds) Caves and Karst of the Yorkshire Dales Volume 1, pp 239-251. British Cave Research Association.
20.  Lord T. C, Thorp J. A & Wilson P (2016). A wild boar dominated ungulate assemblage from an early Holocene natural pit fall trap: Cave shaft sediments in North West England associated with the 9.3 ka BP cold event. The Holocene 26(1): 147-53
21. Minimal Impact Caving Guidelines (2016). Http://british-caving.org.uk/wiki3/lib/exe/fetch.php?media=conservation_access:micg.pdf. Retrieved 2018
22. Murphy P.J (2018). A gazetteer of vertebrate remains from caves in the Yorkshire dales referenced in caving club journals and allied literature http://bonecaves.ubss.org.uk/. Retrieved 2018
23. Murphy P. J & Chamberlain A (2008). Cavers and geoconservation: The history of cave exploration and its contribution to speleology in the Yorkshire Dales. In Burek C, V & Prosser C, D (eds). The History of Geoconservation. The Geological Society, London, Special Publications 300, pp 207-215. Geological Society, London.
24. O’Connor T & Lord T (2013) Cave palaeontology. In Waltham T and Lowe D (eds) Caves and Karst of the Yorkshire Dales Volume 1, pp 225-238. British Cave Research Association.
25. Pacey N (2010). Closing the gap. Descent 215: 23-27.
26. Potholers break through the final Three Counties link (2011, 7 Nov)TheGuardian. https://www.theguardian.com/uk/the-northerner/2011/nov/07/caving-potholing-three-counties-system-gaping-gill-white-scar-caves-edouard-martel. Retrieved July 20, 2015.
27. Ramsey D (2011). The Cupcake Connection. Descent 219: 30&31
28. Ramsey D (2008). Rumbling Extension. Descent 200: 13.
29. St Lawrence H (2009). Trapdoor Pot. Journal of the Red Rose Cave and Pothole Club 10: 31-36
30. Swire P (2009). The Dead Bobbin Series, Rumbling Hole, Leck Fell. Journal of the Red Rose Cave and Pothole Club 10: 311-315.
31. Ukcaving.com (2018). https://ukcaving.com/board/index.php
32. Walker I (2012). Nine months in Crescent Pot. Descent 228: 42-45.
33. Walsh A (2010). The Three Counties System: chasing the dream. Descent215: 18-22.
34. Waltham T & Lowe D (2017). Caves and Karst of the Yorkshire Dales Volume 2 The Caves. British Cave Research Association.
35. Waltham T & Lowe D (2013). Caves and Karst of the Yorkshire Dales Volume 1. British Cave Research Association.
36. Waltham A. C, Simms M. J, Farrant A. R & Goldie H. S (1997). Karst and Caves of Great Britain.Joint Nature Conservation Committee.
37. Waltham T & Brook D (1980). The Three Counties System. Transactions of the British Cave Research Association 7:  121.